This is a good idea Bops.
Even still I think members need to be responsible when posting their opinions about others/guides to the forum and keep it to that section alone. We need to remember this forum is for constructive and not destructive purposes.
I also like your (Bops) suggestion of every opinion/review on a particular guide needs to be detailed and presented with photographic evidence, may I suggest this posting should be subject to review by a designated person, to avoid any future problems that could arise, legal or otherwise .
I have been following posts quite diligently and I have seen “cat and mouse” games being played out where people are soliciting business and indirectly advertising and promoting services. There are very intelligent and well read people on this forum and if someone thinks that things like these “subtitle adverts” go unnoticed, then it is a mistake. I was not going to make mention of this but since it has come up I am just voicing myself, I do not want to get into a debate on this subject and would like to put this to rest right here.
Bops, I also think that your idea is very good, but I reiterate, we need the co-operation of people who want to advertise and promote their services to do so on that part of the forum only. Besides it will also bring in revenue that will help maintain this forum that is fast growing.